Showing posts with label science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label science. Show all posts

Monday, December 27, 2010

Don't open the oven, you'll deflate the souffle

A new study shows just how crazy high rates of pre-term births are. Not good, y'all. Not good.

Long before I was married or pregnant, I was in the "please, schedule the c-section" camp.  Then I decided to pay attention to medical advice and mother nature.  We may have clobbered evolution with medicine and IVF, but we still did spend a few millenia perfecting the birthing process.  Kids need to get squeezed out and they need to get squeezed out at the right time.

Of course, when it came time for me to deliver, I ended up being induced and having a c-section - neither of which I wanted (Ed.'s note: When I say I didn't want them, this isn't a story of "forced" medical intervention. Those stories bother me. Frequently because I don't always trust the victimized mother narrative that comes with them.)  A potentially deadly-for-the-baby condition dictated early induction - though I was already 38 or 39 weeks - and who knows what led to my inability to push the kid out. God know's I tried.

But having gone through a medical induction, all I can say is, ladies, please, don't do this. I know pregnancy sucks. I hated it. And I know, thanks to our fabulously shit-ass parental leave policies that leaving things up to nature means risking leave time with the baby and various employment bads.  But if you'r body was as shut up and unready as mine - holy cow - don't try to force it.  Seriously, don't. 

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Language, Biology, and Boobs

This is an interesting piece on the language of breastfeeding and, somewhat counterintuitively, how the phrase "Breast is Best" might reinforce artificial feeding instead of that best breast product.

The thrust of the article is this: we all would love to be the best, most perfect, ideal parent and give our children the best, most perfect, ideal things. But that's probably not going to happen. So good enough is, well, good enough. And formula is good enough.  If we instead phrased the options as breastmilk = normal, formula = substandard, then the discussion takes on a very different tone and mothers get a substantially different message.

(Note - does this post conflict with post immediately prior? Maybe.  But regular readers of my other blog will know that I love little as much as I love a good linguistics discussion.)

One point that I liked - where's all the milk banks at?  There are some, but you need a prescription to get the goods.
There is a need for standard formula in some situations. Only because we do not have human milk banks. The person who needs additional blood does not turn to a fourth-rate substitute; there are blood banks that provide human blood for human beings. He does not need to have a special illness to qualify. All he needs is a personal shortage of blood. Yet only those infants who cannot tolerate fourth best are privileged enough to receive third best. I wonder what will happen when a relatively inexpensive commercial blood is designed that carries a substantially higher health risk than donor blood. Who will be considered unimportant enough to receive it? When we find ourselves using artificial milk with a client, let's remind her and her health care providers that banked human milk ought to be available. Milk banks are more likely to become part of our culture if they first become part of our language. . . .
.... All of us within the profession want breastfeeding to be our biological reference point. We want it to be the cultural norm; we want human milk to be made available to all human babies, regardless of other circumstances. A vital first step toward achieving those goals is within immediate reach of every one of us. All we have to do is...watch our language.



Things that should go without saying usually should be said

I found a website today about proudly formula feeding mothers. And why wouldn't there be a blog for that - there's so many damn militant lactivists sites.

It's hard to talk about infant feeding without becoming defensive - arguing that formula isn't so bad or that your promotion of breast feeding isn't meant to put anyone down.

Sooooo much wasted energy. 

Formula isn't bad. Mothers who feed their infants formula aren't bad.  It isn't poison.  Telling mothers it is poison is mean, wrong, and stupid.

All mothers, regardless of whether their kid is clamped to a boob or a bottle, should turn their energy toward the culture and PUBLIC POLICY* that guilts them for formula feeding but does nothing to build the community, public interest, or public policy support to enable sustained nursing relationships between moms and babies.  We're not enemies, that's our enemy.

The same site, above, posits that maybe in trying to promote breastfeeding and hide the potential problems from poor, easily dissuaded mothers, we're ignoring actual medical problems that could be remedied with accurate, timely diagnoses or additional research. Here's a long quotation pulled from an even longer post:

What if our initial failure to nurse altered my second stage of lactogenesis, so that my casein/lactose was out of whack? (This might explain why certain kids with MSPI can tolerate breastmilk, while others cannot, despite their moms cutting all potentially offensive foods out of their diets.) I can't help but wonder if we are not just "missing the diagnosis", but missing the mark altogether. Breastfeeding might be natural, but our lives are not. We have children later, are exposed to all sorts of chemicals and toxins, and spend years filling our bodies with synthetic hormones and altering our menstrual cycles. Many of us were only able to conceive with help from medical science. Is it really that impossible to believe that these factors might be increasing lactation problems, or creating new ones altogether?

Tuesday, September 7, 2010

More on sleep

Another piece on infant sleep from Mothering magazine (a source I'm going to have to go "eh" on because of their vaguely anti-vaccine stance. Not cool):

One of the biggest crises of confidence that new mothers face has to do with sleep. Mothers feel responsible for their babies' sleep. Others ask mothers if their babies are sleeping through the night, as if this is something the mothers can control. Mothers lie to one another about whether or not their infants sleep through the night. And everyone lies about not bringing their babies into bed with them.
We lie because our society has unrealistic expectations of babies, and therefore we have unrealistic expectations of ourselves as mothers. Our expectations for babies' sleep simply do not coincide with babies' actual capabilities, or with the normal behavior of our species.
Yeah, I think we all lie. Or we probably should if we're tired of questions about how our babies are sleeping.  Mine still doesn't sleep as well as she used to, but I've stopped grieving the loss of my uninterrupted 5-6 hours and moved the hell along to whatever gets me enough rest to be coherent the next day.  Lately, that's been allowing Fidg to sleep next to me in bed. Or more precisely, allowing me to sleep next to her.  Safely.

I'm pretty sure this is safer than what I had been doing before: arranging myself with the nursing pillow and promptly passing out, only to wake 4 hours later and find both of us at odd angles.  The other night, she straight up fell of the pillow, landing with a soft plop on the mattress.  That's far more dangerous than consciously making the decision to allow her to sleep latched on.  She falls face down and I don't wake up for 4 hours . . . or worse, she rolls of the OTHER side of the pillow . . . . . Scary.

Also unhealthy, for me and her at this time, in my opinion, allowing her to just cry it out in the other room.  Forget the wisdom of the CIO method or Ferberizing your child, I know with a near certaintly that my child wakes in the night because she needs to feed because I don't pump adequate milk to stuff her full during the day time.  Kid's gotta eat sometime.

I need to just relax and let biology rule for a bit longer.  This time won't last forever.  And in some ways, despite me thinking this notion was stupid as hell a month or two ago, that extra time we have together at night makes it easier for me to be gone all day - especially now that she's beginning to notice when I leave.

(Okay, mom?)

Sunday, September 5, 2010

Co-sleeping isn't bedsharing

I never much considered the distinction, but apparently, scientifically speaking, you co-sleep just by having the baby in the room with you, in a crib or bassinet, etc. So we've been co-sleeping with the Fidg since birth.

Lately, however, there's been some bedsharing as  well.  Waking every two hours to feed her was a bit of a drag and moreover, felt unsafe as I couldn't stay awake once I had her on the nursing pillow in bed with me.  If she's on the bed surface to start, she's not going to roll there and land face down or, worse, roll off onto the floor.

I'd prefer to get her back in the crib, but so every so often, she ends up in bed, and routinely ends up there after her 5 or 6am waking since there's just some dozing to be done between then and work.

The above linked article is pretty interesting and worth a read.  I especially like this part which academically chuckles over the paradox created by our cultures relationship with its ethics rules
It remains a curiosity of western cultures that we are largely unable to study prolonged mother-infant separation in a laboratory setting, even though our culture in the US provides us the perfect “natural experiment,” with thousands of neonates and infants being left to sleep alone for long periods of time every night. However, it is reasonable to at least suggest that solitary infant sleep represents an evolutionarily anomalous setting for human babies. As a result, infants may experience a physiological stress response that puts them at risk of energy depletion and immunological depression, while placing undue strain on their developmentally immature respiratory, cardiac, and neurological systems.
 Here's more on the definitions:

Definitions are important here. The term cosleeping refers to any situation in which a committed adult caregiver, usually the mother, sleeps within close enough proximity to her infant so that each, the mother and infant, can respond to each other’s sensory signals and cues. Room sharing is a form of cosleeping, always considered safe and always considered protective. But it is not the room itself that it is protective. It is what goes on between the mother (or father) and the infant that is. Medical authorities seem to forget this fact. This form of cosleeping is not controversial and is recommended by all.